Wednesday, December 2

Economic update

Introduction and risk assessment

As economic trends signal an end to the steep cyclical downturn, future sustained recovery remains problematical amidst conflicting signs. The US economy continues to digest a never ending cocktail of mixed signals to post meager gains which suggest sustainable economic growth is still probably a year or more away.

Globally tentative improvements remain buffeted by stiff headwinds; more conservative capital consuming banks,vulnerability in asset prices,the circumspect consumer and the unwinding of unprecedented monetary and fiscal stimulus packages which increased government indebtedness by 50%. The continued nuclear ambitions for Iran & North Korea also cast a shadow over global outlooks.

The consensus outlook by the Board of the Reserve Bank of Australia is slightly more upbeat for Australia, aided by the resilient economies of China and Asia recovering faster than expected. Australia benefits from these faster growing regional ties and a very modest level of government debt combined with a well regulated banking system. Our risks lie in the relatively high level of household debt secured on residential property; any pronounced weakness in housing prices exerts pressure on a banking system captive to overseas funding. Rising house prices have reduced home ownership affordability by 24% since April this year. Any risk of a pronounced housing price fall is low since housing stock is under supplied and demands continue to flow on from record levels of immigration. Banks reliance on overseas funding leaves the economy vulnerable to any credit squeeze imposed by overseas lenders, because,apart from forced superannuation saving and government surpluses, we remain a nation of spenders not savers. Increased saving remains a key initiative for the country to be more sustainable in the future.

Interest rates

The Reserve Bank of Australia today raised the cash interest rate 25 basis points to 3.75% to record a unprecedented 3rd straight monthly rate increase; expect another rate increase in February 2010 and a cash rates of 5% by 2010. Such increases represent an unwinding of a previous accommodating monetary policy stance in response to the GFC to one that returns to a position of neutrality. The rise in interest rates and in our exchange rate will contain the prices for traded goods and services but dampen growth in the trade-exposed sector of our economy. The Reserve Bank has also expressed some concern over rising house prices and hopes the interest rate increase will dampen consumer sentiment and propensity to continue to pay inflated prices for housing.

The current yield on the Commonwealth Government March 2019 bond is at 5.267 per cent while the yield on the April 2012 bond was at 4.430%.


Because of the continued weakness of the US dollar speculation is rife the US dollar may lose the world’s currency reserve status. Throughout the 18th and 19th century the English pound enjoyed reserve status before an elected dollar came to power, many years after the US had become the world’s largest economy.

Bearing in mind the reluctance for sudden changes, the requirement for deep markets and the need for ease of convertibility you can reliably conclude it will take several decades before any change become feasible.

In the meantime ongoing US Dollar weakness could be a catalyst for continued political and economic tension, particularly if China continues to avoid a Yuan appreciation, although I think fears here are overblown.

Lessons from the great depression and recent GFC after shocks

As the past tumultuous events of the global financial crisis continue to hover in our collective consciousness, inevitable comparisons continue amongst economic commentators and share chartists with the great depression. The great depression was preceded by the roaring twenties which tended to add a flavour of assumed speculation and bubble bursting scenarios to most of the economic commentary at the time and subsequently.

However an analysis of stock indices (earnings to stock price ratios) just prior to the massive falls of the thirties reveals stock price was not excessive except for one industry sector. That sector was the popular leveraged Investment companies whose specialty was utility stocks. As inevitably more realistic profit reports undermined inflated values of utility stocks the leveraged investments companies were forced to sell their entire share holdings to satisfy liabilities to margin lenders. That event triggered a train reaction as investors in their now defunct management investment companies were forced to sell their entire shareholdings to satisfy their margin lenders.

The operative lesson is the extreme danger of gearing. The final straw during the depression that led to the now famous double dip in stock prices was governments action taken to stem perceived greedy speculators initiated by tightening credit which caused widespread panic selling and subsequent larger scale insolvencies due to lack of liquidity.

I don’t think we are in danger of following that same fearful path today but the risk nevertheless remains, particularly whilst the US banking system (unlike Australian) is not adequately regulated and could still inflate a bubble from excess liquidity and leverage.

However Banks in Europe are 25% and in the US 20% bigger now than pre 2007 crash levels -when the cry was heard too big to fail ! This scenario provides is an ongoing challenge to regulators in relation to capital adequacey and to internal risk managers who need to be given authority to influence bank practices and policies.

Another lesson learnt in recent times was it only took the huge indebtedness of one tiny nation - Iceland to undermine the house of cards that had enveloped the globe. Investors are now more recently worried about Dubai; since it has borrowings of $US80billion to finance a 4 -year construction boom now subject to a pronounced property slump. Dubai world surprised markets when it called for a halt on paying back $US60 billion debt until next year. Dubai's debt problems will be well contained, but expect a few more surprises like this over the next year or so until we reach a point of renewed confidence.

US Banking system still inadequate in regulation.

Federal lawmakers and regulatory officials continue to grapple with what new regulations are needed to be introduced to avoid a repetition of the conditions that led to the Global Financial Crisis. Policies and proposed recommendations remain bogged down within the political process with the administration unable to obtain a bipartisan approach. The current US policy settings which ensure the benchmark interest rate remain near zero, carries the risk such an accommodating monetary policy setting, will fuel a surge in assets and the so called “carry trade” risks another bubble occurring. The unwinding of this “carry trade” would not be pretty. The Fed itself is aiming to better identify risks, drawing on its 220 PHD qualified economists to be more effective in identifying potential bubbles and improve regulatory oversight according to a recent article appearing on Bloomberg.

Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke said he doesn’t rule out using monetary policy to pop asset-price bubbles, while stressing that financial regulation is his preferred approach.

Corporate Profits

Disregarding the US fragile banking system the one bright feature is the recovery in corporate profits largely driven by cost cutting and stabilization in inventory levels previously slashed in response to faltering weak demand. However the cost has been high in widespread human misery and unemployment to leaves a continued deep scar well into the future. Given this caveat and apart from the banking sector, most of the corporate sector (with a few notable exceptions) are in relatively good shape and should continue to improve. Historically current stock price earnings ratios are only slightly in excess of long term historical averages to assume an inbuilt profit improvement inherent in 2010, which is also true for Australia and most of the western world.


You cannot legislate morality or a perfect a set of banking indices which alienate risk. Rather, what is needed is for regulators to be prepared through improved training - to get their hands dirty and carry out periodic due diligence's and exercise a common sense regulatory service which demands transparency.
If you can’t understand what is going on that is usually a clear signal that something is fundamentally wrong. If you’re subject to a financial services or banking license it is preposterous to think a company’s operations can rely on a complex computer generated model which generates huge profits and counterparty risk but whose risk profile remains unintelligible or a mystery to inexperienced regulators.

“Banking should be boring – it is boring. When banking becomes exciting, then it becomes very dangerous “

Quote from Mike Smith - ANZ's chief executive who operates one the largest and most profitable successful banks in the world today-'In the black' -December 2009

Gearing ratios vary according to the quality of the risk – if you’re gearing to invest in government bonds ratios of 20 or 30 to 1 won’t matter – if your investments are risky 4 to 1 may be far too much leverage. I am afraid there is no easy answer but a return to integrity and the constant need to evaluate different scenarios with industry experience.

Financial services as an industry also needs to ensure fees and charges are transparent and easy to undestand, just as regulators can incorporate such requirements into sensible regulatory oversight.

Insofar as transparency for operations are concerned free enterprise markets always needed to be transparent to be effective and equitable and nowhere is this more apparent than in the derivatives market. Since the crash we have merely increased market liquidity sufficiently by massive injections of funds to substitute existing counterparty risk with increased liquidity.

There also needs to be more regulatory measures for boards of directors of public entities to set sensible remuneration limits – particularly in relation to draw backs on share options arising in the event of subsequent failed results.

Classic Bank Run

President Barack Obama has blamed compensation tied to excessive risk-taking for fueling the deepest financial crisis since the Great Depression. The administration has named a special master to approve compensation packages at firms that have received the biggest government bailouts.


Richard said...

I'm just waiting for the hyper-inflation that will probably follow the stimulus and recovery.

Mercutio said...

Still the dollar remains the safe haven of choice when the market turns risk averse. And gold as well (sitting now above $1200 again), which has been of great benefit to Australia.

Another thing that really helped Australia was the manner in which cooperation was achieved between business and labor to keep more people employed.

New regulations for day trading accounts have went into effect. Four day trades in a five-day period and the account is tagged as a day trade account. Once it's tagged, there must be a minimum balance of $25,000, or the account must be inactive for 6 months to revert to retail status.

I've opened a retail account at Barclays to take advantage of the better margin rates.

The government housing securities, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, were downgraded about the middle of October. They have lost not quite half their value since then.
There is some type of resolution of the two that is supposed to occur sometime in March, but I don't know the details.
I can only preach the virtues of the stop-loss.

lindsaylobe said...

Hi Ricard & Mercrio

Australian employers have been willing to creatively retain workers during this downturn in marked contrast to previous recessions.

The continuing trend in reduced jobless claims and a payroll decline of only 11k in November hopefully will see the US job market finally stabilize for the March 2010 quarter but future recovery remains uncertain.

The risk of hyper inflation is begining to be more widely appreciated and the US Dollar will strengthen if the Fed undertakes a much needed tightening stance.

I think you will see a move to interest rate increases over the next 6 months to improve US dollar sentiment. In the process Gold will continue to be smashed since its ascendancy was due to a purely a currency/carry trade play.

Best wishes

gfid said...

Canadian stats show gradual growth in GDP and consumer spending, above anticipated rates. meanwhile the oil companies here at home in Alberta continue to roll in record profits, while crying the blues about how the new royalty regulations are hurting them. they cut back on local contracts to convince small, local business that the Alberta govt. is not working in their best interest with these higher royalties for oil production. the small, local companies ARE hurting, thanks to the manipulation of the big oiligarkies, who are most definitely NOT hurting.

and through it all, big new SUV's and pickup trucks continue to roll off the local automotive sales lots in herds. people put fluorescent bulbs in their light fixtures and continue to use the 5 gallon flush of a toilet full of drinking water to dispose of a used kleenex. they build monstrous homes on the cheap, with no thought to the environmental cost of heating them in -40 C.

sorry to rant on your page.... the focus in my 'back yard' on the dollar cost of things, with no thought to their sustainability or environmental impact makes my eyes cross. most of the senseless waste is done by people who have the dollars to behave responsibly, but they won't spend them.

lindsaylobe said...

Hi grannyf - Thanks for your visit and update on Canada which reflects in some respects our experience down under. Alberta however seems to echo some of the sentiments of the Wild West as you aptly explain and I can understand how that would be very frustrating particularly with your commendable involvement in the sustainable sharper end of the economy.
You’re most welcome to rant here at any time on any subject but on a more positive note I can confirm to you both economics and accounting is beginning to focus more on the importance of human capital. Large companies here focus on informative comprehensive reports indicating measures adapted to reduce waste, energy and improve their governance. Such reports measure contributions to all stakeholders – such as suppliers, customers and community. Accounting records support practical measurable outcomes – to give a comprehensive honest scorecard with low and high scores in the various categories. Progress has been good and failures honestly reported give credence to the integrity and honesty of those involved.
Best wishes

Cartledge said...

Well Lindsay, that is giving Gittins a run for his money - most informative as I've been in the backblocks and out of touch.
It seems the USA still don't get it, and perhaps never will. On the other hand I suspect Canada would be in a stronger position if they capitalised on their links to Asia rather than focusing on US markets. I guess it is easy and accessable but fraught with danger.

Seraphine said...

a cocktail of mixed signals. i like that phrase. it's like mixing beer and gin, wine with a singapore sling. no matter what happens, there will be a headache in the morning. at least.
everyone is talking about inflation. it's the logical conclusion.
but really, what happens if there is no recovery? there is a danger in the united states that wealth stops being created. housing values might not go up because americans sinply cannot afford to buy things anymore.
so instead of inflation, perhaps the end result will be a very weak dollar and an economy that refuses to be stimulated. it may be a different kind of inflation than people expect.
i'll take a vodka mojito, please.

lindsaylobe said...

Hi Cart & Sera – Thanks for your visit - I think those mixed cocktails continue to be less dangerous for Australia as China’s construction starts in November are up 200% on the prior year- underpinning future demand for our exports.

The US dollar has continued to strengthen for the December quarter which is good news but as I said until the global banking sector which resides outside countries like Australia and Canada is subject to improved regulation you have those continuing risks of bubbles from excess credit creation.

Tentative improvements are a few years off- but I think there will be a recovery in jobs accompanied by the accelerating shift in economic power to China and India - already evident. But this can be seen as an opportunity to improve outcomes locally for everyone by exporting technology and ingenuity - know how – not as commonly thought of as a negative to relocate jobs offshore. It means the US needs to be more engaged and less insular with a more interntionasl economic focus.
Best wishes

somaie said...

Make Money With Affiliate Programs
How To Make money with affiliate programs Today. Affiliate marketing is the easier and probably the most effective method to make money from the internet. It is basically, a kind of selling technique where potential buyers from your website are directed to the websites of sellers. For every click, the website owner gets a small commission.

Coetsee said...

Make Money With Affiliate Programs
How To Make money with affiliate programs Today. Affiliate marketing is the easier and probably the most effective method to make money from the internet. It is basically, a kind of selling technique where potential buyers from your website are directed to the websites of sellers. For every click, the website owner gets a small commission.

Blogger said...

eToro is the #1 forex broker for rookie and advanced traders.